Mary Catelli's Erraticly Updated and Exceedingly Ill-Organized Journal

One noteworthy difference between Hogwarts and, say, Roke Island in Earthsea.  In Hogwarts, everyone studies magic.  On Roke Island, the school is for specialists, and not even all sorcerers went.
( Read more... )

Was in a discussion of Cursed Child and its flaws. . . . one observation was that in one respect Albus was Slytherin ambitious.

( Read more... )

The Cursed Child did not add much to the details of why the magic is all living in secrecy in the Harry Potter world.  However, it did have one interesting touch -- spoiler warning --

( Read more... )

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child by J.K. Rowling, John Tiffany, and Jack Thorne

Hmmmm. . . . I don't think I'm very fond of this book. Though it had some wonderful moments of gem-like perfection. . . I don't think it worked as a whole.
( Read more... )

Hmmm -- if the wizard society pulled away from Muggles in modern types, as the Harry Potter books say it did, how did wizardly history affect Muggle history?

All those Goblin Wars?  All those dragons?  If they weren't separate, the wizards would have had to re-write history with censorship to prevent notice.  Perhaps recast some of it as fiction.  (A la L. Jagi Lamplighter's Prospero's Daughter trilogy.)

But there might still be traces left where the patch job had to be a bit awkward because nothing could make the omission of magic neat.

Read an article on Harry Potter.  In which the author asked why the wizarding world didn't have TV.
( Read more... )

The elusive sense of wonder.  So hard to get in your fantasy. . .
( Read more... )

Sometimes things leap out when you read a series in rapid sequence.  Like the gifts in Harry Potter.

( Read more... )

One thing I think was inadequate in Deathly Hallows, and thought so the first time, was in the scene where Snape gave up his memories.

( Read more... )

Sometimes when a world-building question gets raised in a story, you have to answer it one way.

( Read more... )